Is a 9/11-Style Investigation Into the Insurrection Even Possible?


“Most commissions don’t succeed,” he warns. “Most of them fail, and their recommendations are not passed or considered — they go up to sit on the top shelf of a bureaucrat’s dusty office, ignored into eternity.”

The 9/11 Commission stood aside, he says, due to its tradition of bipartisanship, respect and clear-eyed method to the information at hand. It convened at a second Congress shared a robust sense of goal to struggle the exterior risk — an environment “conducive to exchange and debate, not sound bites and tweets.”

Today, issues are completely different: The assault is already seen by means of partisan filters, and any new fee could be meeting in a Washington the place disruption itself is a political model. “If any one of these people appointed to the 9/11 Commission were bomb-throwers or people who just wanted to disrupt the process, that by itself could easily have derailed the entire process,” says Roemer. “It only takes one member to do that.”

For all that, Roemer completely believes a new fee is important—and in the long term, might be extra vital than the one he sat on, maybe “the most important commission ever.” He suggests a broad scope, trying not solely at the Jan. 6 assaults, however “how we try to ensure the peaceful transfer of power, what do we do to make sure that conspiracy theories and lies don’t permeate our democratic system of information getting to people, and how we take bipartisan steps forward to strengthen our democratic institutions.”

What can a 1/6 Commission study from the 9/11 Commission? Is it doable to have a broadly accepted bipartisan consensus about the information of the case? And can political allies of President Donald Trump be relied upon to take part in good religion?

To type by means of all of it, POLITICO Magazine spoke with Roemer this week. A condensed transcript of that dialog follows, edited for size and readability.

Before serving on the 9/11 Commission, you have been a member of the House for 12 years. You know the Capitol properly. What was your response whenever you noticed the rebellion final month?

In my public service journey, I’ve had three searing occasions that scorched my soul.

The first was as a fifth grader: After having stayed up all night time to cheer on my hero, Bobby Kennedy, in the California [1968 presidential] main, my mother and father woke me up the subsequent morning to inform me that he had been assassinated.

Second, was as a member of Congress: I used to be on Capitol Hill in a meeting with a number of members — together with Nancy Pelosi — speaking about a management race when the first aircraft went into the [World Trade Center], and we finally needed to scatter out of our office buildings into the streets, the place our cell telephones didn’t work; we later realized that the Capitol was a goal.

The third was January sixth. I used to be riveted to the TV, watching insurrectionists and terrorists ravage our citadel of democracy and threaten custodians, employees members, members of the House and Senate, in addition to the vice chairman of United States — threaten to assassinate them. This was Americans attacking our family.

That’s a large distinction: The rebellion was an assault by Americans — one inherently tied up in partisan politics — and there isn’t something just like the post-9/11 sense of bipartisan unity. Do you assume that adjustments the method that a 9/11 Commission-style investigation into the rebellion would work? How ought to it method its mission?

There are many similarities between 9/11 and the January sixth home terrorist assault on the United States. There are myriad variations as properly, and it’s important to tell apart between the two.

One of the similarities is that each have been extraordinarily violent, in some methods surprising, deliberate bodily assaults on our authorities establishments. On 9/11, it was Wall Street, the Pentagon and the U.S. Capitol, although [United flight 93] was introduced down by courageous patriots in Shanksville, Pennsylvania, earlier than it may hit its goal in Washington; January sixth focused the Capitol. The variety of legislation enforcement casualties on 9/11 was considered one of the highest in our nation’s historical past; January sixth induced horrific and catastrophic harm to our legislation enforcement group.

This question about a January sixth fee’s remit and mission is a necessary one, and one thing I’ve tried to specific to the Speaker [Nancy Pelosi], the speaker’s employees and folks on this [commission] laws: We must get to the backside of the occasions of January sixth. How was it deliberate? How was it carried out? Why did intelligence miss it, or why wasn’t intelligence reported? What did legislation enforcement miss? Was there a position — and what was the position of President Donald Trump or members of Congress? What have been the roles of social media, of disinformation campaigns and conspiracy theories main as much as it, planning it, sharing it and galvanizing folks to be concerned?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here