Press "Enter" to skip to content

Hitting the Books: How Florence Nightingale changed medicine using stats and ‘rose charts’

During Crimean War, hospitals of the day weren’t a lot facilities of therapeutic or recovery as they have been the locations the place injured combatants went to die barely extra slowly. Turkey’s Scutari hospital was one such infamous instance. Converted by the British Empire from military barracks, Scutari lacked each conceivable amenity, from fundamental sanitation to adequate air flow, this “hospital” served as a potent incubator for myriad infectious ailments — that’s till Florence Nightingale and her crew of volunteer nurses arrived in 1854. 

Maladies of Empire by Jim Downs explores what number of facets of recent medicine are borne on the backs of humanity’s most abhorrent impulses, although in the excerpt under, Downs illustrates how one girl’s unyielding tenacity and fastidious file protecting helped launch the area of preventative medicine.

Belknap Press

Excerpted from MALADIES OF EMPIRE: HOW COLONIALISM, SLAVERY, AND WAR TRANSFORMED MEDICINE by JIM DOWNS, revealed by The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. Copyright © 2021 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College. Used by permission. All rights reserved.


While in Scutari, Nightingale developed a system of file protecting that tracked a wide range of components at the Barrack Hospital and the close by General Hospital. She took notes on all the things from cleanliness to the amount of provides to food plan to the placement of latrines and graveyards.

She additionally rigorously examined the bodily house. She took cautious notice of the measurement of the wards, the situation of the roof, and the high quality, measurement, and placement of the home windows. In her ebook on the well being of the British military, like Thomas Trotter and others who wrote about the significance of contemporary air, she pointed to the downside of improper air flow, and she devoted a complete part to “bad ventilation.” She quoted the report of the sanitary fee, which remarked on the “defective state of the ventilation” in the Barrack Hospital. There have been solely “a few small openings here and there,” in order that there was no manner for the “hot and foul” air to flee. As an adherent of the miasma principle, she believed that ailments have been unfold via the air and advocated for air flow to launch the “foul air” from hospitals.

In addition to insufficient air flow, Nightingale pointed to poor drainage and badly designed sewers and plumbing. In her testimony to the royal fee, Nightingale reported on the filthy situations she present in the Barrack Hospital when she arrived. “The state of the privies… for several months, more than an inch deep in filth, is too horrible to describe.” She noticed six lifeless canines below certainly one of the home windows, and a lifeless horse lay in the aqueduct for weeks. The consuming water was soiled; as soon as she noticed used hospital uniforms in the water tank. Rats and bugs abounded, and “the walls and ceilings were saturated with organic matter.”

In the conclusion to her report on the well being of the British Army, she defined, “We have far more data on the sanitary historical past of the Crimean marketing campaign than we’ve upon every other, however as a result of it’s a full examination (historical past doesn’t afford its equal) of a military, after failing to the lowest ebb of illness and catastrophe from neglects dedicated, rising once more to the highest state of well being and effectivity from cures utilized.

“It is the entire experiment on a colossal scale.” She identified that in the first seven months of the Crimean marketing campaign, mortality exceeded that of the plague of 1665 in addition to that of latest cholera epidemics. But throughout the final six months of the warfare, after sanitary reforms had been made, “we had… a mortality among our sick little more than that among our healthy Guards at home.”

Using mortality information that she had collected throughout the warfare, together with home mortality statistics, Nightingale confirmed that between 1839 and 1853, mortality amongst troopers was a lot increased than amongst civilian males: “of 10,000 soldiers [at the age of 20], 7,077 live to the age of 39, out of whom 135 die in the next year of age; whereas out of 10,000 civilians at the age of 20, 8,253 attain the age of 39, and of those 106 die in the year of age following.” Nearly all mortality amongst troopers was the results of illness; “actual losses in battle form a very small part of the calamities of a long war.” Nightingale categorized the causes of dying as “zymotic diseases” (which in the nineteenth century referred to infectious ailments reminiscent of fevers, measles, and cholera), “chest and tubercular diseases,” and “all other diseases (including violent deaths).” Nightingale was important of the military’s classification system for ailments. At the backside of a chart, she notes, “Bronchitis and influenza have no place in the Army nomenclature. The chronic catarrh of the Army Returns is believed to be really phthisis, in the great majority of cases; acute catarrh comprehends both epidemic catarrh, or influenza and bronchitis.”

Nightingale offered statistics using charts, tables, and diagrams, which have been simply starting to seem in analysis reviews, to make it simpler for readers to visualise the comparability she was making. She developed a brand new form of graphic, referred to as a “rose chart,” often known as a coxcomb chart or polar space diagram, to current mortality information from the Crimean War. Each chart, which is laid out like a pie, exhibits information from one year, with the slices representing months. Each slice is split into coloured segments whose space is proportional to the variety of deaths.

One phase is for deaths from wounds, a second for “preventable or mitigable zymotic diseases,” and a 3rd for all different causes. A fast look at the charts of deaths from April 1854 to March 1855 and April 1855 to March 1856 is sufficient to present that many extra deaths have been brought on by illness than by fight, and that total mortality decreased in the second year.

To additional make seen the risks of unsanitary hospitals, Nightingale gathered mortality information for matrons, nuns, and nurses working in fifteen London hospitals who died of the “zymotic diseases” of fever and cholera. She offered tables, which she notes William Farr compiled for her, displaying that the mortality rate of the nursing workers was a lot increased than that of the feminine inhabitants in London; as well as, ladies working in hospitals have been extra more likely to die of zymotic ailments than have been different ladies. She used these figures to argue for the “very great importance” of hygiene in hospitals. “The loss of a well-trained nurse by preventible [sic] disease,” she wrote, “is a greater loss than is that of a good soldier from the same cause. Money cannot replace either, but a good nurse is more difficult to find than a good soldier.”

In her ebook Notes on Hospitals, she retold the story of the British prisoners of warfare who died in a crowded jail cell in India in 1756: “Shut up 150 people in a Black hole of Calcutta, and in twenty-four hours an infection is produced so intense that it will, in that time, have destroyed nearly the whole of the inmates.” Nightingale’s reference to the case is proof for its standing as the prototypical illustration of the want for air flow. And the proven fact that it befell in India exhibits how British medical authorities used data from round the empire.

As a results of her work with massive numbers of sufferers in the Crimean War, Nightingale framed her evaluation like an epidemiologist, by way of populations. She centered on how illness unfold inside a gaggle. She devoted her energies to not altering bedpans or dressing wounds however to learning the structure of hospitals, analyzing statistics, and determining how you can enhance air flow.

The warfare offered her the alternative to match mortality charges in different settings: crowded hospitals, shabby tents, and wood huts. It additionally underscored to her the significance of preventive measures, which constitutes certainly one of the main tenets of recent epidemiology. By publishing her observations, her insights, and tips for hospitals to observe, she hoped to offer a algorithm and tips for physicians to observe to stop the unfold of illness. While efforts to make sure correct hygiene as a technique to guard towards sickness will be traced to Mesopotamian civilization and Sanskrit writings from 2000 BCE, Nightingale’s warnings, particularly, and sanitary reform, extra typically, sparked a important turning level in the center of the nineteenth century that gave rise to preventive medicine. This remodeled army medicine from an enterprise that largely centered on therapy and surgical procedure to 1 that started to have interaction epidemiological questions and points.

All merchandise beneficial by Engadget are chosen by our editorial crew, impartial of our guardian company. Some of our tales embody affiliate hyperlinks. If you purchase one thing via certainly one of these hyperlinks, we might earn an affiliate fee.