Press "Enter" to skip to content

Facebook has held a ‘durable monopoly’ for a decade, FTC says in amended suit

Facebook has held a monopoly over personal social networking for the previous decade, in response to a beefed-up antitrust suit by the Federal Trade Commission filed Thursday. 

The FTC’s amended suit, which comes two months after a federal decide dismissed an earlier model, seeks to power Facebook to restructure or unload property together with Instagram and WhatsApp that it says assist the company squash competitors. 

“Facebook holds monopoly power in the provision of personal social networking in the United States and has held such power continuously since at least 2011,” the FTC wrote, accusing the company of illegally sustaining a “durable monopoly.” 

The new complaint is longer and extra detailed than a Trump-era suit in opposition to the company that was dismissed this June. At the time, Washington, DC, federal Judge James E. Boasberg mentioned the grievance was “vague” and “too speculative” in its arguments. 

In Thursday’s grievance, the FTC retained its core argument that Facebook engaged in a “buy or bury” scheme to eradicate competitors together with Instagram and WhatsApp, serving to the agency safe an unlawful monopoly that hurts customers. 

“Unable to maintain its monopoly or its advertising profits by fairly competing, Facebook’s executives addressed this existential threat by buying up the new mobile innovators, including its rival Instagram in 2012 and mobile messaging app WhatsApp in 2014, who had succeeded where Facebook had failed,” the FTC alleged. 

The FTC’s amended suit comes two months after a federal decide dismissed an earlier model.

But the brand new submitting additionally comprises extra fleshed-out language that appears designed to deal with Boasberg’s issues. In specific, the brand new grievance — which comes in at 80 pages, in comparison with the unique’s 53 — was clearer in regards to the definition of the “personal social media” market. 

The FTC argued that Facebook’s sphere of competitors is separate from on-line platforms like YouTube or TikTok, which customers don’t primarily use to speak with family and friends. Therefore, TikTok’s widespread recognition in the US doesn’t function an argument in opposition to Facebook sustaining a monopoly throughout the sphere of social media platforms that individuals use for personal communication, in response to the FTC. 

“Snapchat is the next-largest provider of personal social networking services, but its user base pales in comparison: Snapchat has tens of millions fewer monthly users than either Facebook Blue or Instagram,” the FTC mentioned. 

Facebook, which has till Oct. 4 to answer the amended grievance in court docket, referred to as the amended suit “meritless” in a Thursday assertion.

“Our acquisitions of Instagram and WhatsApp were reviewed and cleared many years ago, and our platform policies were lawful,” a Facebook spokesperson mentioned. “The FTC’s claims are an effort to rewrite antitrust laws and upend settled expectations of merger review, declaring to the business community that no sale is ever final.”

FTC Chair Lina Khan will not be recusing herself from antitrust actions in opposition to Facebook.
POOL/AFP by way of Getty Images

Facebook’s stock was up 0.1 p.c Thursday afternoon. 

Shortly after Boasberg rejected the FTC’s preliminary petition, Facebook requested that President Biden-appointed FTC Chair Lina Khan recuse herself from antitrust actions involving the company as a result of she had written critically about massive tech in the previous. 

The FTC mentioned Thursday that it had rejected the petition after having “carefully reviewed” it, indicating that Khan is prone to play an lively function in the case. 

Also on Thursday, Facebook revealed a new function referred to as “Facebook Workrooms,” which is designed to exchange in-person business conferences and Zoom calls with a digital actuality world the place persons are represented by avatars.

Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.) accused Facebook of timing the announcement to distract from the FTC information, since Thursday was the final day the FTC was eligible to file an amended grievance underneath Boasberg’s determination.

“Facebook wants to distract you from the FTC’s updated antitrust filing today,” Schakowsky wrote in response to an article in regards to the Workrooms function.